Sell Your Collectibles to Arthur’s

Looking to sell part of your collection, free up some space, or move something that no longer fits what you collect?

Arthur’s Cards & Collectibles is always interested in adding the right cards, sealed products, comics, books, memorabilia, and collections to our inventory.

Whether you have one standout collectible or a larger collection, send us the details and we’ll take a look.

No auctions. No listing fees. No waiting for the right buyer.

What We’re Buying

We’re primarily interested in:

Graded Cards

• PSA, CGC, BGS, SGC, TAG, and other established grading companies
• Rookie cards
• Autographs
• Refractors and parallels
• Serial-numbered cards
• Short prints and variations
• Vintage and modern cards
• Hall of Famers, stars, prospects, and other collectible players
• Select ungraded cards may also be considered, particularly vintage, autographed, serial-numbered, short-print, or other higher-value cards.

Factory-Sealed Products

• Hobby boxes
• Retail boxes
• Blaster and mega boxes
• Factory-sealed packs
• Older unopened wax
• Baseball, football, basketball, soccer, TCG, and non-sports products

Comics

• Graded comics from CGC, CBCS, and other established grading companies
• Key issues and first appearances
• Golden Age, Silver Age, Bronze Age, and select modern comics
• Signed and witnessed-signature comics
• Variant covers and limited editions
• Higher-value raw comics in collectible condition
• Historically significant or culturally important issues

Books

• First editions and early printings
• Signed and inscribed books
• Limited and special editions
• Historically significant books
• Books associated with notable authors, public figures, athletes, musicians, or cultural events
• Higher-value collectible books in desirable condition

Memorabilia

• Autographed baseballs, bats, jerseys, photos, helmets, and other sports equipment
• Music memorabilia, including signed albums, photos, instruments, and related collectibles
• Historical memorabilia, documents, autographs, and other significant collectible items
• Authenticated memorabilia from established third-party authentication companies
• Game-used, player-worn, stage-used, or otherwise provenance-backed items
• Unique, historically interesting, or culturally significant collectibles

Collections & Larger Lots

Have more than a few items?

We’re happy to look at larger collections, dealer inventory, unopened products, inherited collections, or mixed groups of cards, comics, books, memorabilia, and other collectibles.

You don’t need to catalog every item before reaching out. A few photos and a general description are usually enough to get the conversation started.

How It Works

1. Tell Us What You Have

Use the submission button below to send us a brief description of what you’re looking to sell.

Photos are strongly encouraged, especially for individual collectibles, graded items, sealed products, comics, books, and memorabilia.

2. We’ll Review It

We’ll evaluate the item(s) based on factors such as condition, recent market activity, collector demand, authenticity, provenance when applicable, and how well they fit our current inventory.

Not every item will be the right fit, but we’re always happy to take a look.

3. Receive an Initial Offer

If we’re interested, we’ll contact you with an initial offer or request additional information.

There’s no obligation to accept.

4. Complete the Sale

Once we agree on a price, we’ll arrange the next steps for shipping. After the item(s) are received, we’ll inspect them to confirm condition, authenticity, and that they match the description and photos provided.

If everything is as described and no material issues are found, payment will be issued for the agreed purchase price.

If we identify a significant condition issue, authenticity concern, provenance issue, or other material difference from what was originally represented, we’ll contact you before proceeding with the purchase.

Why Sell to Arthur’s?

Deal Directly With a Collector-Run Shop

You’re dealing directly with a business that actively buys, sells, grades, and collects cards, comics, books, memorabilia, and other collectibles—not an automated buying platform.

Skip the Selling Process

Selling individually can mean photographing items, creating listings, answering questions, waiting for buyers, packing orders, and paying marketplace fees.

A direct sale provides another option when convenience and certainty matter more than maximizing the sale price of every individual item.

One Item or an Entire Collection

You don’t need a massive collection to reach out.

We’re interested in everything from individual premium collectibles to larger collections, unopened inventory, and mixed groups of collectible items.

Straightforward Offers

Our offers are based on the current market, condition, demand, expected resale value, and the costs and risks involved in purchasing inventory.

We’ll never pressure you to accept an offer.

---

A Few Things to Know

Submitting an item does not guarantee that Arthur’s Cards & Collectibles will make an offer or purchase it. As much as we would like to, we can’t buy every collectible that comes our way. If we’re unable to make an offer, we’re still happy to help point you in the right direction when we can.

Please note: We are not currently purchasing bulk common cards, large quantities of low-value base cards, or similar bulk low-value material.

All purchases are subject to final inspection and verification of condition and authenticity.

Sellers must own the items they are offering for sale and have the legal right to sell them.

Please do not ship items to Arthur’s Cards & Collectibles unless shipping arrangements have been confirmed with us first.

Local Drop-Offs: We do not currently offer local drop-offs, pickups, or in-person inspections. We hope to offer local service options in the future.

Built by Collectors, for Collectors.