Make Us An Offer

Make Us an Offer

At Arthur’s, we believe collecting should be fun, fair, and within reach. That’s why we’re introducing a new feature that gives you more flexibility when shopping: Make Us an Offer.

If you see something you like (but not quite at the price you hoped for), you can now submit an offer directly on select product pages. It’s our way of keeping the hobby accessible — and letting you ride away with a deal that feels right.

How It Works

  1. Look for the “Make an Offer” button on eligible items.

  2. Enter your offer amount and include any notes or info you’d like us to consider.

  3. We review your offer and get back to you quickly — yes or no.

  4. If accepted, you’ll receive a secure checkout link with your special pricing already applied.

Simple, fair, and no gimmicks. That’s the Arthur’s way.

What Products Allow Offers?

To keep things consistent and customer-friendly, offers will primarily be enabled on:

  • Graded cards

  • Raw singles

These are the items where pricing can vary based on condition, comps, and collector interest — so it makes the most sense to give you some flexibility here.

Occasional Offer-Eligible Items

From time to time, we may allow offers on select non-card products such as vinyl, toys, sealed boxes, or apparel when appropriate. These will be clearly marked with the offer button when eligible.

Items Not Eligible for Offers

Some products will never be eligible, including:

  • Pre-orders

  • Newly released products

  • Items already discounted or running in a promo

These categories typically have fixed pricing and limited availability, so we keep things consistent across the board.

Shoot Your Shot Specials

Want to quickly browse everything that does allow offers?

We’ve put together a dedicated collection under our Featured tab called:

Shoot Your Shot Specials

This collection updates automatically as items become eligible for offers. If you’re the kind who likes to negotiate, bargain, or simply take a chance, this is your spot.

Why We Offer Offers

Because collecting shouldn't be a one-size-fits-all experience. Markets shift, comps change, and sometimes you just feel like making a deal. We get it — we’re collectors too.

“Make Us an Offer” lets you:

  • Get fair pricing without the back-and-forth games

  • Shop with confidence knowing we review every offer seriously

  • Enjoy a hobby experience built around trust, transparency, and fun